How we saw 'others': a Pacific example

Slippery Word, Ambiguous Praxis: 'Race' and Late-18th-Century Voyagers in Oceania / by Bronwen Douglas

in Journal of Pacific History 41 (1) June 2006

ABSTRACT: This paper traces the presence, absence, and shifting connotations of the term 'race' and the idea of human classification in representations of indigenous Oceanian people by navigators, naturalists and artists on 18th-century British and French voyages. These ambiguous usages signified hardening European attitudes to human difference, as the holistic, 'environmentalist' explanations of the natural history of man lost ground to the differentiating physicalism of the new sciences of biology and physical anthropology. However, by correlating the generation of ideas with particular embodied encounters, I question the presumption that voyagers' representations of indigenous people were entirely determined by preconceptions derived from received knowledge and prevailing discourses. I suggest instead that indigenous behaviour and demeanour left latent countersigns in the language, tone and content of such travel literature and art — on which the emergent metropolitan science of man drew heavily to justify its deductions.

Portrait of William Dampier [source]

Individuals at Metropolitan Museum of Art networked locations can access the full text of the article through WATSONLINE.

Comments

[Nicole Peduzzi]

Thank you very much for signaling Bronwen Douglas's paper, Ross! It explores the idea of human classification in 18th-century voyage texts by analysing the presence, absence and shifting valence of the term "race". It is interesting to see how voyagers' representations where linked with changing metropolitan discourses, which influenced the expressions used in the description of different Pacific cultures.